What the science actually says about pressure vs. oxygen
Short answer: Both pressure and oxygen matter in hyperbaric therapy. But there’s growing evidence that mild pressure alone (around 1.2–1.3 ATA) can produce measurable effects—even when breathing room air (no extra oxygen supply)—and that some people improve under those conditions. Results vary by condition, and this is not a substitute for medical care. FrontiersHealth Systems ResearchJAMA Network
Why oxygen % isn’t the whole story
Hyperbaric therapy has two bioactive ingredients:
-
Increased barometric pressure, and
-
Increased oxygen (hyperoxia).
A 2024 review of dosing in hyperbaric therapy emphasised that both components can be active—and that many so-called “sham” groups at 1.2–1.3 ATA room air actually received a low dose of hyperbaric therapy, not a true placebo. In several studies, those room-air groups improved. Frontiers
A quick (friendly) bit of physics
At sea level (1.0 ATA), room air is ~21% oxygen. In a mild chamber at 1.3 ATA breathing room air, the oxygen partial pressure rises by ~30%, roughly like breathing ~27% oxygen at normal pressure. (That’s the gas-law math many clinicians use to explain mHBOT.) Caroline Fife M.D.
What clinical trials show (in plain English)
-
Military RCTs in persistent post-concussion symptoms:
A large JAMA trial compared 1.5 ATA with 100% oxygen to 1.2 ATA room air and to no chamber. Both chamber groups improved, while the no-chamber group improved less—suggesting that pressurised room air is not inert. Other DoD/VA studies show a similar pattern: improvements in both oxygen and room-air pressurised groups, with mixed differences between them. JAMA NetworkUnbound MedicineHealth Systems Research -
Dose analysis across studies (2024):
A recent Frontiers in Neurology dose review documented within-group improvements at 1.3 ATA with room air in some cohorts (and also at higher pressures with oxygen). The authors argue that calling 1.2–1.3 ATA “sham” can be misleading because pressure itself has biological effects. Frontiers -
Healthy volunteer/athlete data (small studies):
In a small 2011 study of healthy adults at 1.3 ATA breathing room air, markers of oxidative stress decreased and fatigue scores improved after a single session (preliminary data; small sample). Hyperbaric Fitness, LLC
Bottom line from the trials:
People can improve under pressurised room air (1.2–1.3 ATA) and under higher-oxygen protocols. Differences between groups are sometimes small or inconsistent, and high-quality evidence varies by condition. Major summaries (e.g., VA reviews) still call for more definitive research. Health Systems Research
So… does adding oxygen “work better”?
It depends on the goal and condition. Higher oxygen fractions at higher pressures can drive more dissolved oxygen into plasma (that’s classic medical HBOT), which is vital for some approved medical indications. But for wellbeing uses and certain symptom clusters, mild pressure with room air has shown meaningful changes compared with no chamber in several studies, even if not always superior to higher-oxygen protocols. JAMA NetworkHealth Systems ResearchFrontiers
Why pressure might help, even without extra oxygen
Scientists propose a few overlapping mechanisms:
-
Slightly higher oxygen partial pressure (even on room air) can raise tissue O₂. Caroline Fife M.D.
-
Pressure-mediated effects (mechanical/physiologic) may influence circulation, gas exchange, and cellular signaling—separate from oxygen %. (The 2024 review highlights pressure and oxygen as independent dose components.) Frontiers
-
Structured rest and ritual of sessions may contribute non-specific benefits (a point raised in commentary around the JAMA trials). Scite
Practical takeaways for mHBOT users
-
If your aim is general wellbeing (rest, recovery, relaxation), mild pressure (≈1.3 ATA) on room air may still be beneficial for some people—even without an added oxygen supply. Evidence exists, but it’s mixed and not disease-specific. JAMA NetworkHealth Systems ResearchFrontiers
-
If you’re targeting a specific medical condition, dosing (both pressure and oxygen %) is more critical, and current guidelines remain conservative about which conditions should use medical-grade HBOT. Harvard Health
Important safety & policy notes (read me)
-
Oxygens equipment is sold for non-medical wellbeing use only. It is not a medical device and not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent disease. Please seek advice from a qualified healthcare professional if you have any health concerns. (General overviews from major medical outlets also urge caution outside approved indications.) Harvard Health
References (selected)
-
Miller et al. JAMA Intern Med (2015): 1.5 ATA oxygen vs 1.2 ATA room air vs no-chamber; both chamber groups improved. JAMA Network+1ScienceDaily
-
VA Evidence Brief on HBOT for mTBI/PTSD: mixed results; room-air pressurised groups often improved; more research needed. Health Systems Research
-
Andrews & Harch. Frontiers in Neurology (2024): Dose analysis showing improvements at 1.3 ATA room air in some cohorts; pressure and oxygen both bioactive. Frontiers
-
Kim et al. Health (2011): 1.3 ATA room air in healthy volunteers reduced oxidative stress and fatigue (pilot data). Hyperbaric Fitness, LLC
-
Caroline Fife, MD (2018): Simple math explainer of partial pressure (why 1.3 ATA room air ≈ ~27% O₂ at sea level). Caroline Fife M.D.